NUNS WEIGH RESPONSES TO SCATHING VATICAN REBUKE: New York Times / Laurie Goodstein.
I have talked at length about American nuns at odds with the
Vatican
on policy or shall we say doctrinal fundamentals. The nuns respond to and
embrace the “signs of the times” or issues of modern life while the Vatican
considers modernity a threat and demands a return to the past.
Nuns are also engaged in serving the sick, the poor,
children and immigrants and not sitting in thrones deciding issues of theology;
the nuns are with the people and on the ground and engaged in the realities of
modern life which often do not jive with Vatican rules.
The nuns are also still engaged in Vatican II and its dictum
to open the church to the modern world while Pope Benedict wants to cancel what
Vatican II tried to do and return to pre-Vatican II times of darkness and
obedience.
The nuns are supposed to be obedient and silent and Benedict
has dispatched bishops to bring the nuns into line with the thinking of
Benedict and not Vatican II.
American nuns are meeting in St. Louis
to come up with a response to the Vatican ’s call to bishops to
overhaul their organization LEADERSHIP CONFERENCE OF WOMEN RELIGIOUS.
Yes, the nuns can bow and accept the bishop’s takeover and
leadership of their organization OR they can form a new organization
independent of Vatican control…wow…most American Catholics are for the nuns and
are cheering them on…and so am I!
The problem the nuns find with the Vatican is that the Vatican regards questioning as
defiance. The same thing happened to me during my Catholic education, when I
asked questions I was told to shut up because the devil is making me ask those
questions; I could never ask, just obey and the nuns are saying no to blind
obedience and yes to discussion because discussion is good for the Church and
its members.
The Vatican
says that the Church must speak with one voice and that is correct but the
Church has not found that voice yet and must work with members of the Church to
develop that voice and it must be a new voice and not the voice of the past.
That is a problem because the past popes were conservatives
and appointed fellow conservatives to positions of power in the Church and
unless a progressive pope is elected which is doubtful given that most
cardinals are conservatives, the nuns have to take leadership roles into moving
the Church into modernity.
I feel that once the nuns resist the pressure from the Vatican , they will be joined by other religious
organizations in pressing the Vatican
to change or at least produce another John XXIII.
LET THE REVOLUTION BEGIN…IT NEEDS TO BEGIN NOW!